INSIGHTS

Pool Is Cloudy but the Chemistry Reads Fine? Start With Cyanuric Acid

Pool test kit and test strips beside a swimming pool with slightly cloudy water

Short answer: if your free chlorine tests in range but the water is dull, cloudy or algae keeps returning, test cyanuric acid (CYA). CYA shields chlorine from UV, but the same binding that protects it also slows it down. The industry consensus target for an outdoor chlorine pool is 30 to 50 ppm, and the working rule is that free chlorine should be kept at roughly 7.5% of your CYA level. At 40 ppm CYA that is about 3 ppm free chlorine. At 100 ppm CYA, the same 3 ppm is no longer enough — and no amount of shocking fixes the ratio, because only dilution lowers CYA.

The ratio table

CYA (ppm) Minimum free chlorine at 7.5% Comment
0 Unstabilised: chlorine burns off fast in summer sun
20 about 1.5 ppm Low but workable; some UV loss
30 about 2.3 ppm Bottom of the recommended band
40 about 3 ppm A common target for an outdoor pool
50 about 3.8 ppm Top of the recommended band
70 about 5.3 ppm Drifting high; sanitiser demand climbing
80 about 6 ppm Most people are not holding this — and that is when algae appears
100 about 7.5 ppm Impractical to maintain; plan a partial drain

Read that column carefully. The chlorine number that was correct at 40 ppm CYA is half what you need at 80 ppm. Nothing about the pool changed except a slow, invisible accumulation.

Where the CYA came from

Almost nobody adds cyanuric acid deliberately. It arrives with stabilised chlorine:

  • Trichlor tablets and dichlor granules both contain stabiliser. Every tablet you float adds CYA that never leaves.
  • Stabiliser or conditioner products are pure CYA, sometimes added on autopilot at opening.
  • CYA does not evaporate, does not break down meaningfully over a season, and is not consumed by chlorine demand. It only leaves in water you take out — via a partial drain, backwash, or splash-out replaced with fresh fill.

That is why pools drift upward year after year: tablets every week, top-ups instead of dilution, and no one testing CYA because the free chlorine reading looked fine.

Fixing a high CYA reading

  1. Test CYA properly. The turbidity test is read at eye level in sunlight; rushed readings run low. Confirm with a second test or a shop test before draining anything.
  2. Work out the dilution. CYA falls in proportion to the water replaced — replacing a quarter of the volume with unstabilised fill cuts CYA by roughly a quarter. Standard guidance for pools above the recommended band is to drain and refill 25 to 50 percent, repeating if needed.
  3. Check local rules and your pool type before draining. Vinyl liners can float and fibreglass or high-water-table sites can be damaged by a deep drain — drain in stages.
  4. Change the chlorine source. If CYA keeps climbing, switch from trichlor tablets to liquid chlorine or cal-hypo, which add no stabiliser.
  5. Re-balance after refill. Fresh fill water changes pH, alkalinity and calcium hardness as well.

If CYA is fine, it is the filter

Cloudy water with correct, in-ratio chemistry is a mechanical problem. Work down this list:

Check What you are looking for Fix
Filter pressure vs clean baseline 8–10 psi above clean start pressure Clean the cartridge or backwash
Cartridge condition Flattened pleats, oily grey film, torn ends Deep-soak, or replace — cartridges are consumables
Run time Whole volume should turn over daily Increase pump hours before adding any chemical
Sand or DE media Channelling, old sand, missing DE charge Recharge DE after every backwash; replace sand periodically
Pump basket and skimmer Restricted flow, air in the lid Clear baskets; check for a suction air leak
Return jets Dead spots with no circulation Aim jets to rotate the whole pool, angled slightly down
Calcium hardness and pH Scale-forming water clouds up Re-balance before chasing it with clarifier

Clarifiers and flocculants are the last step, not the first. A clarifier clumps fine particles so the filter can catch them — which does nothing if the filter is the problem.

Quick answers

Can I lower CYA with a chemical? Products exist, but partial drain and refill is the standard, reliable method. Dilution is the only mechanism you can calculate in advance.

Does CYA matter in an indoor pool? Much less — without UV there is little to protect chlorine from, so stabiliser mostly just slows the chlorine down.

Do saltwater pools need CYA? Yes. A salt chlorine generator still makes chlorine that sunlight destroys, so the same stabiliser logic applies.

Why does algae keep coming back after shocking? Usually because the free chlorine is falling back below the CYA-adjusted minimum within a day. Fix the ratio, not the symptom.

How often should I test CYA? Monthly through the season is plenty, plus once at opening and once after any large refill.

Shop pool care

Pool chemicals and water testing · filters and cartridges · cleaners, vacuums and skimmers · pumps and circulation · pool and spa replacement parts · Hayward · Pentair · Intex. Free US shipping.